Operation Christmas Child is a massively popular program run by Samaritan’s Purse, a Christian organization headed by famed evangelist Billy Graham’s son, Franklin. Every year about this time hundreds of thousands of kids in elementary schools, youth organizations, and church groups in the United States and other countries collect shoeboxes filled with Christmas gifts to be sent to needy children in hundreds of countries across the globe. Samaritan’s Purse has delivered more than 135 million such boxes since 1993.
The appeal of Operation Christmas Child is obvious. It’s a well-run program and it’s an easy way for affluent children (and their parents) to share the Christmas spirit, to give a tangible expression of love to the less fortunate. Christian organizations also like the fact that OCC shoeboxes are sometimes accompanied by literature sharing the Gospel message and giving an opportunity to get involved with a local church.
In spite of its popularity OCC isn’t without controversy. Some allege that Franklin Graham’s salary is disproportionately high compared to presidents of other charitable organizations. Others claim that Samaritan’s Purse downplays (or hides) the evangelical nature of Operation Christmas Child leading to awkward situations where non-Christian children are inadvertently participating in an activity contrary to their own faith. Still others are bothered by the fact that Franklin Graham is an outspoken critic of Islam, a partisan stance most humanitarian relief organizations try hard hard to avoid.
But even assuming they’re all irrelevant or false, these criticisms completely miss a bigger issue. Operation Christmas Child might be a good tool for evangelism, but it’s a lousy aid program. Here’s why:
- OCC does nothing to directly address the long term needs of the children receiving the gifts or their parents. (Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach him to fish and you feed him for a lifetime. Give a shoebox full of toys to one of his kids and you…?)
- Toys (particularly cheap, plastic toys) and candy are some of the worst things you can give to children who really need access to health care, education, and nutritious food.
- The people who derive the most economic benefit from OCC are Chinese toy manufacturers, and shipping companies. The local economies of the countries where the toys are handed out receive no benefit from OCC and may actually be harmed. (If you were the local toy store how would you feel when the OCC boxes arrived?)
- OCC hopes to deliver 12 million boxes in 2016. At $7 per box, the shipping fees alone amount to $84 million. Imagine the impact that money could have if it was donated directly to local non-profits and pumped into local economies instead.
- OCC does not have enough in-country staff to equitably distribute the shoeboxes. They have to rely on volunteers and partner organizations who determine to whom, when, and how the boxes will be given. Sometimes this works well, other times it does not. (In 2001 I witnessed an OCC shoebox delivery at a Special Olympics event in Managua, Nicaragua turn into a political campaign rally as everyone had to sit through a presidential candidate’s campaign speech before he got the honor of passing out the boxes.)
- It’s difficult to buy toys in the United States that are not directly tied to some aspect of North American culture. We’re exporting our language, our sports, our music, our movies, and our Disney princesses without any regard for the cultural context of the children on the receiving end.
When it’s all said and done, Operation Christmas Child is an easy program that does more to help Americans feel good about ourselves at Christmas time than it does to help fulfill the long-term needs of the less fortunate.
They’re not as flashy and you do not get as much personal satisfaction donating to them, by there are other organizations which achieve better, longer-lasting results with your money than Operation Christmas Child. Here are just a few:
Last summer after spending most of my life in Colorado, my family and I made a big transition to living in South Central Massachusetts. Before that I had spent very little time east of the Mississippi and the first time I ever set foot in New England was for the job interview. It’s been an interesting journey to say the least. Here’s what Massachusetts seems like to a life long Coloradan.
- There is no way anyone could navigate here without a GPS system.
- Every intersection has an odd number of roads at random angles.
- Saying “go straight,” “go right, or “go left” often means the same thing.
- The longest stretch of flat, straight road is 1/8 mile.
- With all the trees, average visibility is around 50 feet.
- Road names change every five miles.
- Every road is named “Providence” at some point.
- Apparently anyone turning left has the right of way; everyone is so used to people turning left in front of them, they anticipate it, stop and wait.
- You can buy house anywhere from 1 to 200+ years old in the same part of town.
- Options for heating a house include coal, wood, pellets, oil, electricity, natural gas, and/or any combination of those.
- Houses with a garage but without a pool are strangely rare.
- Mailboxes are only on one side of the street; our mailbox is in our neighbor’s yard.
- The humidity makes the heat feel hotter and the cold feel colder.
- Owning a dehumidifier is an absolute must.
- Everything is really green in the summer, really red in the fall, and after the leaves fall you suddenly find neighbors you didn’t know you had.
- Drive times are no longer negligible; everything is 30 minutes away.
- You routinely drive to other states.
- Electrical outlets look funny.
- Alternating snow and rain is common.
- Regular people really do speak with a Boston accent; they save up the ‘r’s from some words to add to the ends of other words.
- Pop is “soda,” shopping carts are “carriages,” and (my favorite) drinking fountains are “bubblers.”
- It gets dark at 4:30pm in the winter.
- Watching “prime time” sports on the east coast means staying up past midnight.
- Everything is more expensive.
- People are not trusted pumping gasoline; the pump handles don’t lock in the on position and most gas stations are full service.
- There isn’t a Starbucks in sight but there is a Dunkin’ Donuts on every corner.
- As far as fashion goes, you can wear any color/pattern with any other color/pattern. Pink shorts on men is normal.
- Bow-ties are strangely popular, even with the students.
- Students have much better attendance but don’t seem to care as much about their grades.
- There’s no fluoride in the water. We have to get prescriptions for fluoride pills.
- You can’t throw a rock without hitting a cemetery.
- There are three drive-in movie places within a 20 minute drive, more than there are McDonalds.